911 Audio Reveals Baby Was ‘Breathing,’ ‘Moving’ After Attempted Arizona Abortion

Photo Credit: Markus Knigge
Photo Credit: Markus Knigge

PHOENIX, Ariz. — Newly-released audio footage of a 911 call from an Arizona abortion facility reveals that a child who had been scheduled for an abortion was breathing and moving after exiting the womb.

The incident occurred in February at Family Planning Associates in Phoenix, Arizona, operated by abortionist Edward Allred.

The child’s 27-year-old mother had arrived to complete the abortion of her 21-week-old (5 month old) baby, which is “legal” under Arizona law. She had taken an abortifacient two days prior as per the facility’s instructions, which was to have stopped the child’s heartbeat.

However, the baby survived the medicinal stage of the abortion, and the mother went into labor as the surgical procedure began.

Abortionist Eleanor Stanley asserted that she found no heartbeat after the baby was born, but when workers noticed the baby moving on the scale, one exclaimed, “Oh my G**! This fetus is moving!”

They then called 911. It is required under federal law for abortionists to provide medical care to survivor infants and not leave them to die.

“We are a termination clinic. There was a termination that was performed,” an employee explains to the 911 dispatcher. “There is a fetus who is breathing right now so we need someone to do services.”

  • Connect with Christian News

The dispatcher then asked if the baby had been harmed in any way; the worker said no.

“The fetus is breathing so we need care for it now,” she said. “We can’t provide that care except for oxygen, and we’re trying to keep the fetus stable until someone arrives.”

The baby died minutes after arriving at the hospital, and pro-life groups held a vigil for the child, who they named Chava, a Hebrew word meaning “life.” NARAL Pro-Choice America has now decried the concern, stating that pro-lifers “pushed to make this a bigger story than it needed to be.”

But some state that the incident demonstrates a number of important facts.

“I do know this: You had a human being that was born, a human being who died,” attorney John Jakubczyk told local television station WKYC.

The pro-life group Live Action also notes that it had conducted an undercover investigation at the same facility several years prior and was told that nothing would be done to care for infants who are born alive. Abortionist Laura Mercer, who was questioned by the 23-week pregnant investigator, said not to call 911 as “they would intervene and do all kinds of crazy things that you don’t need to have done to you.”

“So why did the facility worker call 911 in this case? There is no way to know,” the organization states. “Perhaps the baby’s mother, realizing her baby was alive and moving, had a change of heart and wanted to save her child. Perhaps a worker took pity on the baby; or it could be that due to Live Action’s investigation, the worker knew they were being watched very carefully by pro-lifers.”

The discussion is wider than just the Phoeonix facility. As part of a Congressional investigation, the House Select Panel on Infant Lives also subpoenaed Maryland abortionist Leroy Carhart this month to provide “policy and procedures … including any training provided to staff on how to care for an infant born alive.” Carhart is suspected of allowing babies to die after surviving abortions—a violation of federal law.

Become a Christian News Network Supporter...

Dear Reader, has ChristianNews.net been of benefit and a blessing to you? For many years now, the Lord has seen fit to use this small news outlet as a strong influential resource in keeping Christians informed on current events from a Biblical worldview. Striving to bring you the news without compromise and with Christ in focus, we press on despite recent changes in Facebook and Google's algorithms, which has limited our readership, and, as a result, has affected operational site revenue. If you have benefited from our news coverage, please prayerfully consider becoming a Christian News Network supporter by clicking here to make a one-time or monthly donation to help keep the truth widely and freely published and distributed. May Christ continue to be exalted through this work! Would you join us by making a donation today to this important work? >>

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
  • Tom Hanig

    Maybe the abortion clinic killed the baby before emergency help arrived. There should be an investigation since this could be a homicide.

    • Alison Mohr

      This article does state that the baby died minutes AFTER arriving at the hospital. However, abortion is always homicide!

      • Ambulance Chaser

        Really? What statute classifies abortion as homicide?

        • Alison Mohr

          God’s Holy Word

          • Ambulance Chaser

            Okay, that’s not a US law. So, none, is what you’re saying?

          • Alison Mohr

            God’s law trumps man’s any day

    • LadyFreeBird♥BlessedBeTheLord

      They tried to kill before the baby was born But they failed to kill this baby. The baby died at the hospital.

  • TheBottomline4This

    Wonder what Hillary Clinton would say. She’s on record saying that an unborn baby is a person.

    • Nidalap

      Obama is on record as being in favor of the infant being killed at that point. The mother’s wishes, don’cha know…

      • TheBottomline4This

        Most Liberals are so into death. Abortions, assisted suicides, death of certain things in culture, They are blinded to what they really are supporting.
        Yet, they cry for gun control to “save lives”.
        Hypocrites much?

        • The Last Trump

          Yeah. That sounds like them alright.

          • TheBottomline4This

            lol, you said it 3 times…ya sleepy? 😉

          • The Last Trump

            I missed out on the conversation! 🙁
            Gonna put in my two cents worth anyway! 🙂
            You guys just lined them up for me beautifully!

          • TheBottomline4This


      • The Last Trump

        Yeah. That sounds like him alright.

    • Josey

      She would throw her blood stained hands up in the air and say, “what difference does it make now, the baby died.”

      • The Last Trump

        Yeah. That sounds like her alright.

  • Grace Kim Kwon

    Abortion should get done away with. It is murder.

  • ComeOnPeople!

    Whoa unto a society which legalizes the killing of the weakest among them. America is heading towards profound immorality. They legalized the killing of the innocent and are attempting to legalize to assist the weak in body & mind in the killing of themselves.

  • sammy13

    May the little one rest in the arms of the Lord.

    More proof that abortion is murder, carried out by callous individuals.