Canadian Judge Rules Pro-Life Group’s Bus Ad ‘Likely to Cause Psychological Harm’ to Abortive Mothers

GRANDE PRAIRIE, Alberta — A judge in Canada has upheld a city’s decision to reject a pro-life advertisement from being displayed on transit buses, stating that it is “likely to cause psychological harm” to mothers who have obtained an abortion.

“I find the city’s decision to reject this particular ad was reasonable,” wrote Justice C.S. Anderson of the Court of Queen’s Bench in Alberta. “I find the ad is likely to cause psychological harm to women who have had an abortion or who are considering an abortion. It is also likely to cause fear and confusion among children who may not fully understand what the ad is trying to express…”

The Canadian Centre for Bioethical Reform (CCBR) had submitted an advertisement to the transit authority of the City of Grand Prairie that included two photographs showing the stages of fetal development. One photograph depicted a baby in the womb at seven weeks, and another portrayed a baby at 16 weeks. Next to the images was a bloody circle representing abortion.

“7 weeks growing, 16 weeks growing, gone,” the advertisement reads. “Abortion kills children.”

According to Anderson, Grand Prairie officials rejected the banner because they believed it could incite ill will against “an identifiable class: women who have chosen to exercise their legal right to have an abortion.” The judge agreed.

In issuing his decision, Anderson noted that the CCBR website reads, “Now is the time to put an end to the slaughter. Now is the time to look evil in the face and say, enough. Now is the time to join together, and lend our voices to those who had theirs brutally taken from them.”

“These are strong statements that vilify women who have chosen, for their own reasons, to have an abortion; they are not merely informative and educational,” he wrote.

  • Connect with Christian News

Anderson also noted that those who view the ad will be a captive audience, that they cannot help but see the message.

“The Charter guarantee of freedom of expression is meant to protect not only those who wish to express themselves but also those who are the recipients of the expression,” he said.

Abortion advocacy groups applauded the decision.

“The right to free speech depends on respect for your audience and their right to avoid your message,” Joyce Arthur of the Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada told reporters. “The decision is significant, and shows that anti-choice groups like the CCBR are wrong to wield their right to free speech like a bludgeon against the public.”

But CCBR said that free speech isn’t really free if it is censored.

“If government can tell its citizens what’s upsetting and what isn’t upsetting in their speech, then democracy is threatened and, indeed, progress is threatened,” Carol Crosson, legal counsel for the CCBR, opined.

“You might as well not have free speech at all,” also said John Carpay of the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms. “Free speech doesn’t mean anything if it doesn’t mean the right to say things that are offensive and outrageous. If it just means you can spout platitudes acceptable to the majority, it is worth nothing.”

A special message from the publisher...

Dear Reader, because of your generous support, we have received enough funds to send many audio Bibles to Iraqi and Syrian refugees displaced by ISIS in the Middle East. Many have been distributed and received with gladness. While we provide for the physical needs of the people, we seek to provide the eternal hope only found in Jesus Christ through the word of God. Would you join us by making a donation today to this important work? Please click here to send an audio Bible to a refugee family >>

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
  • Charles Findlay

    Unmitigated propwash. The judge should have his head read.

  • Grace Kim Kwon

    So they don’t care about the life of children set for murder-abortion??

  • Fran Dunham

    That’s called guilt.

  • Lisa Dell

    This is BS. Some people just can’t handle the truth of what happens to the development of the baby in the womb, and of what it looks like after it has been aborted. I have seen even worse pictures then these ones.

  • This style 10/6

    In Canada we don’t lay guilt trips on women who exercise the right to control their own bodies.

    • Robert

      even in Canada a bible is easly obtainable. Christian women know they were bought with the price of Gods own blood and their bodies belong to him.they also know women that do not have Jesus there bodies minds and souls are nothing but slaves to sin death and the devil.

      • This style 10/6

        Oh, give over, do!

    • Neonic

      In America, a MAN who causes the death of a fetus can be charged with a felony, which is right. Unfortunately, the laws allow a woman to kill her own fetus. This needs to be corrected.

      Feel who kill should feel guilt.

      If they don’t, send them to prison anyway, maybe they’ll find the leisure time to grow a conscience.

      • This style 10/6

        Sure, fill the prisons up with women. You already have the world’s highest incarceration rate.

        In Canada we have no laws on abortion.

  • Robert

    a very temporary judgement from a very temporary judge. We christians know of a final judgement where this very temporary judge will be Permently Judged . this Judge wont be even a tad bit bold then.