Feminist Professor Says Polygamy is the Next Marriage ‘Civil Right’


A college professor in Vermont has released a book in support of polygamy, explaining why she believes it is the next civil right in America.

Janet Bennion is a professor of anthropology and sociology at Lyndon State College in Lyndonville. Earlier this year, she released a book entitled Polygamy in Primetime: Media, Gender and Politics in Mormon Fundamentalism, outlining her research on the topic and why she supports the idea of a woman or man having two or more spouses.

Recently, Bennion sat down with the Vermont publication Seven Days to further explain her views on polygamy, as she has been studying the lifestyle for over 20 years, and even spent time herself among a polygamist group. Bennion, who said that she does not wish to be a polygamist as she is happily married to one man, outlined that much of her book is based on talks with Mormon women or those involved with the Apostolic United Brethren.

“The groups vary, and some women find that working with other women in the home is beneficial to them,” she told the publication. “One woman described her co-wives as ‘second mothers’ [who do the childcare], so she can go find a job in the community. They have this economical and social network that provides a little bit more freedom than you might see in a monogamous pair bond.”

Bennion said that while most modern Mormons no longer follow polygamist doctrine, there are a number of them who still do.

“[T]he mainstream is made up of people with ancestors who were polygamists,” she added. “You can see that there are some sensitivities there, especially in an election year. Half of my family was for Romney, the other half for Obama. The Romney half was saying, ‘You shouldn’t have that book out there.’”

The professor advised that lesbianism even exists within polygamist relationships. She said that she received “love letters” once from a married woman, and was also invited to dinner by another who wanted to see if she was marriage material.

Connect with Christian News

“There are women in the Utah pioneer days who formed a sisterhood network and allowed for lesbian connections,” Bennion stated. “I talked to at least three women who had formed sexual connections to their sister wives or to another woman in the community.”

She said that she feels that those who oppose polygamous marriages are bigots.

“We need to just step back, get off our high horse, and look at this from a civil liberties perspective. If we’re going to pave the way for alternative sexuality, why not provide liberties for those who choose the polygamy form?” Bennion asked. “As a feminist, I say, ‘Bring it on; let’s legalize it.’”

However, others are not supportive of this concept at all.

“I think our country was based upon [the resolve] that we would uphold the traditional view of things as outlined in the Bible,” Chip Thompson, director of Tri-Grace Ministries in Ephraim, Utah, told Christian News Network. “Polygamy places our country and children in what are not healthy situations.”

He pointed out that in the Bible, while some in the Old Testament had been involved in polygamous relationships, it still was not right.

“In none of these cases do we end up with a pretty picture,” Thompson explained. “We see jealousy, we see abuse, we see lots of things that we wouldn’t want to promote.”

He felt that such relationships are especially damaging to children.

“There are regulations in the New Testament that God did not want polygamist leaders leading His Church,” Thompson continued, pointing to 1 Timothy 3, where Scripture outlines that a bishop must be “the husband of one wife.” “I think God did that on purpose. He does not want it promoted.”

Thompson, who has been ministering to Mormons and its various sects, such as the Allreds, the True Living Church and the fundamental LDS, says that despite polygamy being illegal in the nation, it is prominent in Utah.

“All throughout Utah … there’s a lot of polygamy,” he said. “Mormons do espouse polygamy, but [for some] not now. … They believe that polygamy is a part of their eternal existence if they are exalted.”

In recent months, polygamy has made its way back to the spotlight, especially due to reality shows such as TLC’s Sister Wives and HBO’s Big Love.

“I think marriage is under attack,” Thompson stated. “I think the family is under attack.”


What do you think? Discuss this article...

3 Responses to Feminist Professor Says Polygamy is the Next Marriage ‘Civil Right’

  1. In the Fundamental Latter Day Saints (FLDS) church, polygamy is a common practice and is called “plural marriage.” It is not illegal per se, but nevertheless such “plural marriages” are recognized by the government. This does not prevent FLDS men from claiming ONE woman as a wife for the purpose of federal recognition and benefits.

    Similar situations are actually pretty common in our broader society. There are many men and women who are married, yet still have other sexual partners. Those additional sexual partners are basically ignored for the purpose of government benefits. I suppose you could call this “polygamy” if you want to, but the people involved in such “friends with benefits” arrangements would probably not use that term.

    Polygamy as a government-recognized domestic arrangement is its own issue and must be addressed on its own merits or lack thereof. It has no more to do with Gay couples getting married than it has to do with Straight couples getting married. The whole “slippery slope” argument is really getting tiresome.

    • Pardon me, I meant to say that “plural marriages” are NOT recognized by the government.

    • Chuck,
      What I’m tiring of are people who are clueless to know that the ‘slippery slope’ is at least sometimes TRUE!
      You just read the article (Well, in Nov 2012), and it shows the polygamy ADVOCATE who CONFIRMED the critic’s ‘slippery slope’ argument. She alleged that in the Mormon “Utah pioneer days”, some of those polygamous wives had LESBIAN relationships among each other, and she talked with 3 present-day polygamist wives who have “sexual [lesbian] connections with a co-wife or another woman in the community. She calls those who disagree BIGOTS, insults non-conformists by telling them to “get off their high horse” – like the entire set of reasons are just an ego trip, self-righteousness’, etc – uses more STANDARD PC Leftist same-sex marriage & GBLT issues advocacy buzzwords & buss terms as calling the issue one of “civil LIBERTIES”, refers to “ALTERNATIVE sexualities” & then slips down that bad ol’ slope – IF we are going to let OTHERS, think same0-sex couples, have their way paved, why not other consenting adults in what “alternative” “form” they CHOOSE for themselves. She ends by saying we should “legalize” the polygamous “ALTERNATIVE SEXUALIT[Y]“.
      You gotta be blind not to see what is right before your face.
      She CONFIRMS & SUBSTANTIATES the LEGITIMACY of the critic’s “slippery slope” argument.
      Let’s get off the slope by rejecting the redefining & watering down of gender, family, and marriage.
      There are also good arguments, factually based, why we should not have legalized same-sex marriage, without using the slope, but the slope is legitimate to use, and should be as a secondary argument.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>