Judge Finds Preacher Guilty of ‘Disorderly Conduct’ for Preaching to Patrons Near Noisy Bar

McPhersonBryn Mawr, Pennsylvania — A Christian preacher who engaged in street preaching to patrons of a Pennsylvania bar district last month has been found guilty of disorderly conduct for his activities.

Jim MacPherson told Christian News Network that he joined other local Christians on a Saturday night to share the Gospel on the streets of Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania out of their desire to be a light in the darkness. It was his first time ever to street preach.

“God placed a heavy burden on my heart to minister to the lost people who are out in the world, because that’s who I was three years ago,” he said.

The men originally set up down the street from Kelly’s Taproom, a popular hangout for college students, especially on the weekend. One man stated that he could hear the song “Sweet Caroline,” which was being played inside the bar, all the way at the end of the street. He also noted that the establishment has a history of complaints over its rowdy night club atmosphere, which continues into the early hours of the morning.

However, as MacPherson and others began preaching and distributing tracts to passersby, they were the ones approached by police.

“The officer pulled up and he basically tried to figure out what we were doing, because I guess it’s not something that is common practice in Bryn Mawr,” he explained. “He said that we were okay to be out preaching.”

However, MacPherson outlined that the officer was unsure of the content of the local noise ordinance, and kept returning after checking on matters with his supervisor. During this time, the men had moved across the street from the bar and were reaching out to a number of people coming and going from the establishment.

  • Connect with Christian News

“The officer said that we were fine [to preach], but that if he received any complaints that he would come back and ask us to turn it down,” he stated.

Approximately an hour and a half later, Officer Swain returned after receiving a complaint from local resident Paul McNabb, who was walking the streets that night to “patrol” the area. McNabb is known in the community for lodging complaints against activities that he opposes, including the loud music emanating from Kelly’s Taproom.

“At that point, I was the one preaching,” MacPherson explained. “I feel like Mr. McNabb just didn’t want us there that night. … If he wanted to silence me, then he got what he wanted.”

MacPherson then ceased preaching and the men moved across the street simply to talk with people coming and going from the bar. However, approximately 30 minutes later, Swain’s supervisor arrived and cited MacPherson for disorderly conduct for making “unreasonable noise” by preaching across from the bar — even though MacPherson had stopped speaking altogether.

When asked why the bar was allowed to blast music into the streets, but MacPherson was cited for preaching, the sergeant replied, “It’s a Saturday night. It’s a liquor establishment, and it’s … the normal business hours for that establishment.”

Video footage of the discussion with police further captures one of MacPherson’s friends taking issue with the logic of the sergeant.

“[Y]ou still have music that can be heard all the way across a four-lane street, somewhere down a half a block here, and you’re going to allow them to do that,” he said. “I think it’s unfair that we would be cited when this facility can blare its music and do what it’s doing.”

On Tuesday, MacPherson appeared before Magisterial District Judge Kathleen Valentine, who found him guilty of disorderly conduct. Valentine required that MacPherson prepay nearly $450 in order to obtain a hearing, which included $300 in fines and other related costs.

“I didn’t feel that the judge actually judged what the law said,” he stated. “The law is very clear that I had to have intent to harass, annoy or alarm or recklessly create a risk thereof in harassing or alarming, and she mentioned nothing of creating a situation like that.”

MacPherson explained that Valentine outlined that she personally knows McNabb, which he felt robbed him of the right to a fair trial.

“The judge said that she knows Mr. McNabb well [and] that we should trust him,” he said. “I didn’t think it was fair that the judge seemed to have a relationship with the complainant, who wasn’t even at the trial, but she seemed to know his motivations.”

He advised that he plans on appealing the decision in hopes of having the case heard by an impartial fact finder.

“Hopefully, I’ll get a judge that doesn’t know the complainant,” MacPherson stated. “I’m definitely going to take it to the next judge and pray for a just outcome.”

In addition to seeking an appeal, MacPherson said he was going to continue to take the Gospel to the streets.

“We have such a great opportunity to reach people for the name of Jesus that we should be going out, and you can’t let some bully with a badge push you around,” he asserted. “[T]hey’re not the law — they’re the law enforcement, and they don’t get to decide that our rights can be taken away.”

“The Constitution is very clear that our rights are given to us by God — that we are endowed by our Creator with these rights,” he continued. “And we’re not endowed by a police officer with these rights, and we’re not endowed by a judge either.”

MacPherson immediately took to the streets to preach following his conviction.


A special message from the publisher...

Dear Reader, our hearts are deeply grieved by the ongoing devastation in Iraq, and through this we have been compelled to take a stand at the gates of hell against the enemy who came to kill and destroy. Bibles for Iraq is a project to put Arabic and Kurdish audio Bibles into the hands of Iraqi and Syrian refugees—many of whom are illiterate and who have never heard the gospel.Will you stand with us and make a donation today to this important effort? Please click here to send a Bible to a refugee >>

Print Friendly