Florida Kindergartner Allegedly ‘Not Allowed to Pray’ Over Lunch

GabriellaOVIEDO, Fla. — The parents of a kindergartner in Florida have pulled their child from public school after they state that their daughter told them that she was recently not allowed to pray over her lunch.

Marcos and Kathy Perez had been considering homeschooling their five-year-old daughter Gabriella, but advise that the alleged incident put matters over the top. Gabriella attends Carrillon Elementary School in Oviedo, and her father works as vice president of sales at the Christian book publisher Charisma House.

The Perez’ state that their daughter told them recently that one of her lunch monitors had spotted her praying over lunch and stopped her from doing do. When they asked her again about the matter to ensure that the story was true, they emailed the school and recorded a video of Gabriella outlining the incident in her own words.

“I was about to pray and say something to Jesus,” Gabriella explained, showing how she had put her hands together and bowed her head. “My lunch teacher told me when I was about to say something, she said, ‘You’re not allowed to pray.’”

“[I said] ‘It’s good to pray,’” the kindergartner continued. “And she just said, ‘It’s not good.’”

The Perez’ contacted Principal Analynn Jones, who then spoke to staff members about the issue and to outline that students have the right to pray in school. But Jones says that none of the teachers recall the incident.

“The situation as stated by the parent has not occurred according to the school’s investigation,” Michael Lawrence, communications officer for Seminole County Schools told WKMG-TV. “We’re dealing with very young children here, so there’s quite a bit of an opportunity for miscommunication to occur. The timing and the issues were very odd considering that the first thing that happened was that a video was done; it was on YouTube.”

  • Connect with Christian News

However, Gabriella’s parents state that they believe her daughter, and remark that they didn’t think anyone at the school would own up to their actions.

“I told her she did the right thing,” Kathy Perez told the Orlando Sentinel. “I don’t doubt for a minute that my daughter is telling the truth.”

The Texas-based Liberty Institute has now offered free assistance to the family, and recently sent a letter to officials at Carrillon Elementary School, requesting that it openly admit wrongdoing and take measures to prevent further problems with students.

“To resolve this issue amicably, we ask that the school district issue a public apology for this instance of religious discrimination and announce the steps it is taking to ensure this does not happen in the future on or before April 7, 2014 to avoid any enforcement actions,” the letter read.

“The principal has pretty much dismissed this,” attorney Jeremiah Dys told reporters. “Saying a five-year-old cannot pray over her chicken nuggets and mac and cheese isn’t in line with the Constitution.”


A special message from the publisher...

Dear Reader, our hearts are deeply grieved by the ongoing devastation in Iraq, and through this we have been compelled to take a stand at the gates of hell against the enemy who came to kill and destroy. Bibles for Iraq is a project to put Arabic and Kurdish audio Bibles into the hands of Iraqi and Syrian refugees—many of whom are illiterate and who have never heard the gospel.Will you stand with us and make a donation today to this important effort? Please click here to send a Bible to a refugee >>

Print Friendly
  • tesa

    children can set the example,we must support the future young evangelicals

  • Tammy Binghan

    Walker Holland, did it occur to you they dont want the person fired, just educated as to what our constitutional rights actually are! Constitutionally we age guaranteed freedom OF religion… not freedom from religion!

  • Michael Penrod

    Good for you little lady. God will bless you. You stand strong in your faith and don’t let the enemy stop you from praying. This is our america too. The enemy is not allowed to stop us from praying to God. They have pushed long enough. Its time for us to stand in the face of the enemy and declare the name of the Lord and His reighteousness. The Lord God will protect you from the enemy and your bravery in the time of war against your salvation is not in vain little warrior. God bless and keep you.

  • Karate Kathleen

    I notice the principal cleverly stated “no teacher” recalls the incident but never mentioned if a lunch monitor did, and the issue happened with the lunch monitor not a teacher! Ya’ll catch that? That makes me think her words were a clever denial without outright lying. and of course the principal has dismissed it, she wants this issue buried as soon as possible.

    In response to Brenda, I can see what your saying but I think the parents are really trying to protect their daughter and not put too much on her at her age. Remember, as grown-ups we too find it hard to stand under harsh pressure because it hurts! But for sensitive little ones as young as she is, it might be too much. It takes gradual time and practice to get that “tough skin.” I pray in the name of Jesus that God will watch over & bless this precious child all the days of her life, and be with her always!

    and to the child I would say it’s OK to pray to God in secret sometimes too, he will always hear you! No matter what!

  • venetta

    I agree totally with Kathleen.
    Also why doesn’t the school allow the child to look at all the dinner helpers so she can identify this person? and maybe they all should have name badges on, children need protected.