Christian Legal Group Proposes New Policy to Protect Girls From Boy Using Womens’ Restroom

RestroomFLORENCE, Colo. — A California-based Christian legal organization has proposed a new policy to Colorado school district officials in an effort to sufficiently protect girls in one school district who state that they feel uncomfortable with a boy that has been using their restroom.

As previously reported, according to the Sacrament0-based Pacific Justice Institute (PJI), parents of teenage girls at Florence High School contacted PJI last year to express concern after their daughters said that a boy, who identifies as a girl, had been using the restroom and making inappropriate comments. The male student reportedly uses the boys’ and girls’ restrooms interchangeably, and is thus not consistent in his gender identity.

However, when parents approached school officials about the matter, they were informed that the male student must be permitted to use the girls’ facilities.

“Our students are in a scenario where they’re being told, ‘If you don’t want to be in this situation where this guy walks in while you’re in the bathroom, then you’ve got to confine yourself to one staff bathroom that is very inconvenient, that’s not even open all the time that they’re on campus for athletic activities and things like that,” attorney Matthew McReynolds told WND. “[They’re being told that] you just have to give up your right to use the other dozen or so bathrooms on campus. You just have to clear out so that this one other student can do whatever he wants.’”

Therefore, in an attempt to reach an agreement that would satisfy both sides of the matter, PJI submitted a draft policy to the Florence-Penrose School District last month.

“District staff shall make every effort to accommodate students who exclusively identify with the opposite biological and anatomical sex, but in a manner that is consistent with other students’ reasonable expectations of privacy,” it reads. “In any case where a sincere objection is raised to the use of a gender-specific facility by an affected person who uses such facility on the basis of anatomical gender identity, the District shall reasonably accommodate such objection and provide alternative facilities for persons claiming gender based on non-anatomical factors.”

“Such accommodation shall include any case involving undressing in the presence of others in a gender-specific facility,” it continues. “In gender-specific facilities, such as restrooms and locker rooms, as well as in off-campus activities such as sleeping arrangements on overnight school trips, administrators and staff shall be sensitive to the privacy needs of all students.”

  • Connect with Christian News

Superintendent Rhonda Vendetti told the Daily Record that the school board will discuss the proposed policy during its workshop on February 10th.

Brad Dacus, president of PJI said that he believes the policy is necessary to protect students in such sensitive settings.

“The opposition has grappled to paint us as hateful people for simply wanting to protect the privacy of all children,” he said. “We recognize that there are those who sincerely struggle with identifying with their natural gender—and we’re sympathetic to their challenges—but it doesn’t change the fact of their biological sex. As such, this policy will help ensure that not just some, but all students have the privacy they deserve.”

A special message from the publisher...

Dear Reader, because of your generous support, we have received enough funds to send many audio Bibles to Iraqi and Syrian refugees displaced by ISIS in the Middle East. Many have been distributed and received with gladness. While we provide for the physical needs of the people, we seek to provide the eternal hope only found in Jesus Christ through the word of God. Would you join us by making a donation today to this important work? Please click here to send an audio Bible to a refugee family >>

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
  • Sir Tainly

    I never have considered before such thorny issues as these, mostly because I have never had reason to consider it.

    The proposed legislation makes sense in a way, may be simplistic, and my experience leads me to consider it likely that it will not really address the issues in a way that will not be unfair to some.

  • Dan

    It seems to me that if they really cared about their students it would only be acceptable for him to use the adult restrooms.

  • David

    They should label the bathrooms “Male Genitalia” or “Female Genitalia”. That way it does not Identify him as a boy or a girl, just which genitalia he currently has.

  • James Johns

    well said David, the states that have these laws should employ that idea asap.

  • Karate Kathleen

    David has the answer!