19 State Attorneys General Back School District’s Refusal to Allow Girl in Boys’ Restroom

mens-room-1486667-640x480-compressedWASHINGTON — 19 state attorneys general have signed a joint legal brief backing a Virginia school district’s appeal of a ruling requiring that it allow a female student who identifies as male to use the boys’ restroom.

“The attorneys general are again stepping forward to protect children by asking the United States Supreme Court to allow school districts to avoid placing young children of opposite sex in the same bathroom or locker room,” South Dakota Attorney General Marty Jackley said in a statement this week.

The Supreme Court brief namely takes issue with the Obama administration’s recent directives to school districts nationwide, which require the accommodation of students’ “internal sense of gender” under threat of losing federal funding.

“This case is about whether federal agencies receive deference when they attempt to impose conditions on the state’s receipt of federal funds, especially when those conditions conflict with the plain text of the statute authorizing the grant and when they appear for the first time in an informal letter issued without opportunity for notice and comment,” the legal filing reads.

“To threaten the states with loss of all of their billions of dollars of federal education funding if they fail to adhere to the department’s command is, plain and simply, coercion—and this court’s federalism jurisprudence does not permit it,” it states.

The brief is led by West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey, and is joined by Attorneys General Luther Strange of Alabama; Mark Brnovich of Arizona; Mike Dewine of Ohio; Ken Paxton of Texas; Jeff Landry of Louisiana; Brad Schimel of Wisconsin; Timothy Fox of Montana and Jim Hood of Mississippi, among others.

The governors of North Carolina and Kentucky also joined in the amicus curiae brief.

  • Connect with Christian News

As previously reported, Gavin Grimm, now 17, told reporters in December 2014 that she began using the boys’ restroom after obtaining permission from the school principal when she expressed disapproval over being forced to use the nurse restroom.

“I’m not a girl. I’m not using the girl’s restroom,” Grimm stated. “So I said, ‘Hey, where can I use the restroom?’ … And so they said, ‘Use the nurse’s room,’ and at the time I was fine with that, because I was still afraid—I didn’t know how my peers would react. So, I didn’t want to push the envelope any further than I had to all at once.”

But she said that the option soon became a problem.

“The nurse’s office is at least a three minute walk from the class I have closest to it. It took a substantial amount of time out of my class time, and it was embarrassing,” Grimm said. “When you’re gone for 15 minutes at a time to use the bathroom, what are high schoolers gonna think? It’s humiliating and it’s alienating.”

The student therefore asked the principal about the matter, who suggested that Grimm go ahead and use the men’s restroom since she identifies as a boy. But some of the parents of the male students soon learned about the allowance, and the issue turned up before the school board.

Due to the concerns of parents, the board voted to approve a policy requiring students to utilize the restroom that correlates with their biological gender, or to use a private bathroom.

But in response, Grimm sued the Gloucester County School Board with the aid of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) in an effort to overturn the policy.

“By excluding Gavin—a transgender boy—from the boys restrooms because the school board does not deem him to be ‘biologically’ male, the school board, under color of state law, has treated and continues to treat Gavin differently from similarly situated students based on his gender,” the suit asserted.

Last September, District Court Judge Robert Doumar, appointed to the bench by then-President Ronald Reagan, ruled against Grimm, disagreeing with the ACLU that the board had violated Title IX with its restroom policy.

“Title IX prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex and not on the basis of other concepts such as gender, gender identity, or sexual orientation,” Doumar wrote.

The ACLU appealed the decision to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, which ruled 2-1 in favor of Grimm in April by pointing to the Obama administration’s recent interpretations of the federal statute.

It then sent the case back to Doumar, who was instructed to rule in light of how the U.S. Department of Education views the federal statute. Doumar consequently ordered the board to allow Grimm to use the boys’ restroom.

The the Gloucester County School Board then appealed the order to the U.S. Supreme Court, asserting that it will cause “irreparable harm to the board, to the school system and to the legitimate privacy expectations of the district’s schoolchildren and parents alike.”

In August, the court granted the emergency injunction, blocking Grimm from using the boys’ restroom—at least for now as it decides whether or not to accept the board’s appeal.

A special message from the publisher...

Dear Reader, because of your generous support, we have received enough funds to send many audio Bibles to Iraqi and Syrian refugees displaced by ISIS in the Middle East. Many have been distributed and received with gladness. While we provide for the physical needs of the people, we seek to provide the eternal hope only found in Jesus Christ through the word of God. Would you join us by making a donation today to this important work? Please click here to send an audio Bible to a refugee family >>

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
  • TheBottomline4This

    Born a male, you will die a male.
    Born a female, you will die a female.
    Pretending, “thinking” or “feeling” you are the opposite sex than who you were born is a mental issue.
    If you were born with a genital birth defect, there are tests to tell you the sex you were born and are.
    It’s simple. Learn to accept who you truly are.

  • Trilemma

    People need to learn to accept who they truly are and that seems to be what Gavin is trying to do. People also need to learn to accept other people for who they truly are.

    • Jimmy

      I think you forgot a ‘not’ in between ‘Gavin’ and ‘is’. You are right, people need to accept others for who they “truly” are. Gavin is truly, scientifically, genetically, legally, and technically a boy.

      • Trilemma

        I am truly, scientifically, genetically, legally, and technically brown haired and brown eyed but that is not who I am. My body doesn’t define who I truly am. Neither does Gavin’s body define who Gavin truly is. As a society, we need to accept a person for whom they really are and not try to make everyone conform to strict binary roles. I don’t think it’s that big of a deal if Gavin uses the high school boy’s restroom. However, I don’t think it’s a good idea for Gavin to use the high school boy’s locker room and showers.

        • Jimmy

          Are you a man or a woman?

          • Trilemma

            People who are transgender use mirrors all the time. Hasn’t changed who they are.

          • Jimmy

            Neither does what they believe.

          • Trilemma

            Neither does what you believe about them. Since they’re in a better position to know who they truly are than other people, it’s up to other people to be willing to accept them for who they truly are and not try to make them conform to be someone they’re not based on some unfounded belief.

          • Jimmy

            Are you a man or a woman?

          • Trilemma

            I identify as a man.

          • Jimmy

            So you don’t know for sure. That’s pathetic.

  • Nidalap

    When the inmates are put in charge of the asylum, only the sane will be called crazy…

  • Grace Kim Kwon

    Good. USA reached mankind’s ideal when the nation gave the equal rights to all colored people. After that, she’s been battling against the troubles which only her own boredom causes which comes from having everything in life. The godly English created a utopia on earth, but it does not last when people are haughty against God and get depravity. USA needs humility before God to be truly happy.